 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Speed Leagues » Molitor Delahanty League » Paul Molitor League » Rule voting
wolfwood83
My goal is to move this process forward and finalize potential rule changes to make a merger with the EDL a strong possibility. If something you vote for ends up in the minority, I will open communication with you to see if that specific rule is something you MUST have, or if it is simply something you are interested in, but are ok with not having.
As I am having board issues I am posting my votes on this initial post:
The proposed rule changes are:
1 - Injury System 2 - i side with the majority
2 - Retirement system 2 - YES
3 - Win percentage modifier - Majority
4 - One Day Pause after draft - Majority
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - YES
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - Majority
***note*** If any of my votes are in the minority, I change them to whatever the majority has voted.
FYI Injury 2 has strong momentum in the EDL
Draft day population - in a 24 team league, there are around 150 prospects. I think the extra time from what the PML is used too would be nice.
Catcher Rule of 70% is from the EDL - I really don't give a hoot on this, but if you do, please say so :)
[Edited on 2-24-2015 by wolfwood83]
Rule voting
February 24, 2015 at 05:26PM View BBCode
This thread is for voting on new rule changes for a proposed merger with the EDL. I will not post any voting on rules that are not a change to the PML's current set, with excepetion to one rule that seems to be split evenly.My goal is to move this process forward and finalize potential rule changes to make a merger with the EDL a strong possibility. If something you vote for ends up in the minority, I will open communication with you to see if that specific rule is something you MUST have, or if it is simply something you are interested in, but are ok with not having.
As I am having board issues I am posting my votes on this initial post:
The proposed rule changes are:
1 - Injury System 2 - i side with the majority
2 - Retirement system 2 - YES
3 - Win percentage modifier - Majority
4 - One Day Pause after draft - Majority
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - YES
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - Majority
***note*** If any of my votes are in the minority, I change them to whatever the majority has voted.
FYI Injury 2 has strong momentum in the EDL
Draft day population - in a 24 team league, there are around 150 prospects. I think the extra time from what the PML is used too would be nice.
Catcher Rule of 70% is from the EDL - I really don't give a hoot on this, but if you do, please say so :)
[Edited on 2-24-2015 by wolfwood83]
KillerG
2 - Retirement 2 - yes
3 - Win % - Majority but lean towards no.
4 - 1 day pause - yes
5 - Draft pop Aug 15th - yes
6 - Catcher 75% - yes I think you meant 75% not 70% does it really matter.
February 24, 2015 at 06:39PM View BBCode
1 - Injury system 3 but I have no issue with system 2 if the majority wants system 22 - Retirement 2 - yes
3 - Win % - Majority but lean towards no.
4 - 1 day pause - yes
5 - Draft pop Aug 15th - yes
6 - Catcher 75% - yes I think you meant 75% not 70% does it really matter.
hclobo
But will accept whatever majority decides.
All others I'm fine either way.
February 24, 2015 at 07:00PM View BBCode
3 - Winning Percentage Modifier. YES.But will accept whatever majority decides.
All others I'm fine either way.
waveslayer
February 25, 2015 at 10:17AM View BBCode
injury system 2 yes the rest dosnt matter what the rules are
femgo
2 - Retirement system 2 - NO (too predicted, not real at all)
3 - Win percentage modifier - NO (bad team will always suck, if we want to make anti-tanking rules, I would rather have a draft lottery)
4 - One Day Pause after draft - YES
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - YES
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - I side with the majority
If I'm in the minority in any of those (probably I'll be) it wont be a problem for me and I'll side with what the majority has voted.
[Edited on 2-25-2015 by femgo]
February 25, 2015 at 11:17AM View BBCode
1 - Injury System 2 - NO (In a league inflated with talent like this one, I like more injuries)2 - Retirement system 2 - NO (too predicted, not real at all)
3 - Win percentage modifier - NO (bad team will always suck, if we want to make anti-tanking rules, I would rather have a draft lottery)
4 - One Day Pause after draft - YES
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - YES
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - I side with the majority
If I'm in the minority in any of those (probably I'll be) it wont be a problem for me and I'll side with what the majority has voted.
[Edited on 2-25-2015 by femgo]
WormStars
February 25, 2015 at 06:42PM View BBCode
I vote no on the win percentage modifier. I also vote no for the retirement system change. Everything else is fine.
TheProfessorAND1
2 - Retirement system 2 - doesn't matter
3 - Win percentage modifier - no
4 - One Day Pause after draft - yes
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - yes
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - doesn't matter
February 26, 2015 at 01:02PM View BBCode
1 - Injury System 2 - no2 - Retirement system 2 - doesn't matter
3 - Win percentage modifier - no
4 - One Day Pause after draft - yes
5 - Draft population date Aug 15 - yes
6 - Catcher rule of 70% - doesn't matter
am47107
February 28, 2015 at 03:27AM View BBCode
Yes to draft date and injury the rest I am fine withPages: 1