 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Speed Leagues » Cool Papa Bell League » Poll: Draft Class Reveal Date
| Poll: Poll: Draft Class Reveal Date | |
|---|---|
| Keep 9/1 Reveal | 0 |
| Move Reveal to 8/1 | 5 |
| Move Reveal to between opening day and 8/1 | 3 |
| Move Reveal to earliest date possible | 7 |
| No preference | 1 |
TheBigKahuna0
Options:
Keep 9/1 reveal - It's tradition! Also keeps the influence of the draft class out of pre-deadline negotiations.
Move reveal to 8/1 - Allows buyer/sellers to have a better understanding of the value of their draft picks when performing mid-season trades.
Move reveal to between opening day and 8/1 - This catches all the dates between the start of the year and 8/1. Some have thrown 7/1 out as an option. Same advantage as 8/1, just opens that window of knowing the value of draft picks earlier. If this option wins, we'll have to expand the lists of options - I'm trying not to muddle them too much on this vote
Move reveal to be as early as possible - Ditto above.
No preference - You don't have to have an opinion, just pick this one so we don't wait for you to vote.
Poll: Draft Class Reveal Date
September 05, 2017 at 06:16PM View BBCode
The thread got started, figured we should get a count of which way the wind is blowing.Options:
Keep 9/1 reveal - It's tradition! Also keeps the influence of the draft class out of pre-deadline negotiations.
Move reveal to 8/1 - Allows buyer/sellers to have a better understanding of the value of their draft picks when performing mid-season trades.
Move reveal to between opening day and 8/1 - This catches all the dates between the start of the year and 8/1. Some have thrown 7/1 out as an option. Same advantage as 8/1, just opens that window of knowing the value of draft picks earlier. If this option wins, we'll have to expand the lists of options - I'm trying not to muddle them too much on this vote
Move reveal to be as early as possible - Ditto above.
No preference - You don't have to have an opinion, just pick this one so we don't wait for you to vote.
TheBigKahuna0
I like the idea of having the draft class in mind when dealing draft picks. This should help facilitate some deals which is only a good thing in my mind. And the earlier the better! I don't see a downside to having the draft always available other than making August a really interesting month with a 8/1 reveal.
September 05, 2017 at 06:23PM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
In the other thread, I talked about moving the date to the earliest possible. I think it's more in line with how real drafts work. In an ideal state, the ranks would change over time and get fixed at a certain later date, but that's just my pipe dream.
I like the idea of having the draft class in mind when dealing draft picks. This should help facilitate some deals which is only a good thing in my mind. And the earlier the better! I don't see a downside to having the draft always available other than making August a really interesting month with a 8/1 reveal.
2Below
My math says we can move up the reveal.
Can we?
I got some more trades to make...
:spin:
September 07, 2017 at 10:59PM View BBCode
Well, that is 9 for earlier with 1 abstention.My math says we can move up the reveal.
Can we?
I got some more trades to make...
:spin:
TheBigKahuna0
Hopefully we can get a few more votes and maybe a winner or at least something new to try for next season.
September 08, 2017 at 03:39PM View BBCode
Heading that way but it won't happen until next year at the earliest. Of the customization to this league, none have happened mid-season. We also have to wait on our site admins to get in and make the change.Hopefully we can get a few more votes and maybe a winner or at least something new to try for next season.
femgo
I do that to owners who haven't voted on the HOF and it is impressive how fast people vote after a u2u message, you think that all owners read all the threads but it is not always the case, also some owner might have read it and forget to vote.
September 08, 2017 at 06:02PM View BBCode
Kahuna, a good idea to make everyone vote is sending a u2u to all owners with the link of the poll.I do that to owners who haven't voted on the HOF and it is impressive how fast people vote after a u2u message, you think that all owners read all the threads but it is not always the case, also some owner might have read it and forget to vote.
jjensen92
September 08, 2017 at 10:08PM View BBCode
I think I voted in a different post but I say move it to 8/1
TheBigKahuna0
Any strong objections to moving the draft reveal to the earliest date? And does anyone know when that is?
September 12, 2017 at 05:05PM View BBCode
Looks like as early as possible is our winner. Two votes are uncast and its 6 to 4 with moving to 8/1 as the second choice.Any strong objections to moving the draft reveal to the earliest date? And does anyone know when that is?
Beanballs
http://beta.simdynasty.com/leaguerules.jsp?leagueid=377
September 12, 2017 at 05:10PM View BBCode
In the 24 team beta the draft reveal date is 4/1 at 11pm:http://beta.simdynasty.com/leaguerules.jsp?leagueid=377
paulcaraccio
i think the change will have to happen in the offseason. there's no opposition to moving it up, though there is a healthy contingent that only wants it at 8/1. I don't remember what I voted for. I'm sure nobody will be too hurt by whatever we decide. I'm game for anything, maybe 7/1 would be a good place to land.
September 14, 2017 at 03:26AM View BBCode
for this season it will be 9/1.i think the change will have to happen in the offseason. there's no opposition to moving it up, though there is a healthy contingent that only wants it at 8/1. I don't remember what I voted for. I'm sure nobody will be too hurt by whatever we decide. I'm game for anything, maybe 7/1 would be a good place to land.
TheBigKahuna0
September 14, 2017 at 06:00PM View BBCode
Since the vote is 6 to 5, I think meeting the middle makes sense. This is obviously something we can revisit after a couple of seasons.
Beanballs
September 14, 2017 at 11:32PM View BBCode
In the other thread I recommended 7/2 (the halfway point of the seasons), but what is a sim day among friends! I am good with anytime earlier...
paulcaraccio
September 15, 2017 at 12:25AM View BBCode
the class would actually be revealed on league date 7/2. It would be something like "11pm after league reaches 7/1", and 7/1 is an off day, so after Game 81, the calendar moves to 7/2 and we'd see the class later that day. If we picked 7/2, we wouldn't see the class until after Game 84.
paulcaraccio
September 15, 2017 at 03:47PM View BBCode
edit, 7/2 would be the same as 7/1 since the calendar turns right to 7/2 after 6/30. im an idiot, carry onPages: 1