 |
View Old Forum Thread
tworoosters
Feel free to play, or comment on analysis.
Why I made the Deal
January 14, 2009 at 10:19PM View BBCode
Rather than have me analyze every trade I thought I'd start a thread where owners can offer their own reasons for their trades.Feel free to play, or comment on analysis.
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Cleveland Buckeyes. The Cleveland Buckeyes receive Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4183150]Dummy Dahlen[/url].[/i]
By the beginning of 2003 I'd made the decision to begin the rebuild. A multi positional backup OS35 year old is pretty much worthless for a rebuilding team so I dealt out Dahlen for a 3rd round pick.
With the "no CP" minor league system a 3rd rounder can have some value, I ended up with [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552925]Carl Williams[/url] a long shot relief prospect with decent control.
Dahlen to Cinci
January 14, 2009 at 10:24PM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
[i]4/8/2003
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Cleveland Buckeyes. The Cleveland Buckeyes receive Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4183150]Dummy Dahlen[/url].[/i]
By the beginning of 2003 I'd made the decision to begin the rebuild. A multi positional backup OS35 year old is pretty much worthless for a rebuilding team so I dealt out Dahlen for a 3rd round pick.
With the "no CP" minor league system a 3rd rounder can have some value, I ended up with [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552925]Carl Williams[/url] a long shot relief prospect with decent control.
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4518993]Paul Johnson[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (BOS).
Similar logic to the Dahlen deal, Johnson is a nice asset for a contender but I sure didn't need him and the "3rd round No CP rule" was in my head.
I ended up dealing out this pick in a future deal which I'll explain when I get to it. Philly used the pick to acquire [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552900]Tony Nichols[/url], who is now on the waiver wire.
Johnson to Boston
January 14, 2009 at 10:29PM View BBCode
4/25/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4518993]Paul Johnson[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (BOS).
Similar logic to the Dahlen deal, Johnson is a nice asset for a contender but I sure didn't need him and the "3rd round No CP rule" was in my head.
I ended up dealing out this pick in a future deal which I'll explain when I get to it. Philly used the pick to acquire [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552900]Tony Nichols[/url], who is now on the waiver wire.
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4293506]Reggie Dunlop[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4949532]Pat Gallegher[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468420]King Bennett[/url], Draft Pick - 2004 Round 1 (BOS).
Well now the rebuild was official. This was one of the most difficult deals I've made, I loved Dunlop and he was only 30 with A+ power both ways and good speed but he had to go if I was going to add assets. We tried about a dozen permutations and combinations, I really wanted [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868663]Urbino[/url] but Albiez wouldn't budge so I took this deal.
I really like Gallegher, he's got great power and red letter health and was only OS24. My faith in him appears justified as he had a solid rookie year and should be a solid regular, maybe occasional All Star, for a decade. Bennett isn't a sure thing but he's got room to grow and might be a 200-250 at bat guy platooning against RHP if he can get to A+/B+.
I knew the first round pick would be #15 or 16 but I didn't know the draft would be so weak, but that's a risk you take when acquiring picks. I ended up with [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552871]Ezell "Easy" Barnes[/url] a hard throwing left handed teenager who needs to get seriously luck with control improves to contribute, but I was stunningly short on pitching depth so he'll stay in the system as long as possible. I had him ranked 10th overall.
Dunlop to Boston
January 14, 2009 at 10:42PM View BBCode
5/1/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4293506]Reggie Dunlop[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4949532]Pat Gallegher[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468420]King Bennett[/url], Draft Pick - 2004 Round 1 (BOS).
Well now the rebuild was official. This was one of the most difficult deals I've made, I loved Dunlop and he was only 30 with A+ power both ways and good speed but he had to go if I was going to add assets. We tried about a dozen permutations and combinations, I really wanted [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868663]Urbino[/url] but Albiez wouldn't budge so I took this deal.
I really like Gallegher, he's got great power and red letter health and was only OS24. My faith in him appears justified as he had a solid rookie year and should be a solid regular, maybe occasional All Star, for a decade. Bennett isn't a sure thing but he's got room to grow and might be a 200-250 at bat guy platooning against RHP if he can get to A+/B+.
I knew the first round pick would be #15 or 16 but I didn't know the draft would be so weak, but that's a risk you take when acquiring picks. I ended up with [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5552871]Ezell "Easy" Barnes[/url] a hard throwing left handed teenager who needs to get seriously luck with control improves to contribute, but I was stunningly short on pitching depth so he'll stay in the system as long as possible. I had him ranked 10th overall.
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Kansas City River Cats. The Kansas City River Cats receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4518885]Jeremy Grey[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868776]Charlie Sherry[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468236]Kyle Champion[/url] , Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (KC).
Another compromise, this started as my offer of [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4353003]Pembleton[/url] for Sherry and [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5086996]Pinson[/url] but Pinson was not to be had so we ended up here. I still think Pembleton is a better pitcher than Grey but Grey is younger and has very nice numbers.
I wanted to get back an ML ready pitcher and a top prospect in any deal for Grey or Pembleton and I think accomplished that here.
Sherry is a reasonable #4 and will still be around to help in five years and I really like Champion. Champion improved almost a full grade last year and has another two years of prime improves, his arm might be questionable at SS but we'll see. The pick is in 2005 so maybe the pool will be a little deeper.
Grey to Kansas City
January 14, 2009 at 11:29PM View BBCode
5/17/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Kansas City River Cats. The Kansas City River Cats receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4518885]Jeremy Grey[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868776]Charlie Sherry[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468236]Kyle Champion[/url] , Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (KC).
Another compromise, this started as my offer of [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4353003]Pembleton[/url] for Sherry and [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5086996]Pinson[/url] but Pinson was not to be had so we ended up here. I still think Pembleton is a better pitcher than Grey but Grey is younger and has very nice numbers.
I wanted to get back an ML ready pitcher and a top prospect in any deal for Grey or Pembleton and I think accomplished that here.
Sherry is a reasonable #4 and will still be around to help in five years and I really like Champion. Champion improved almost a full grade last year and has another two years of prime improves, his arm might be questionable at SS but we'll see. The pick is in 2005 so maybe the pool will be a little deeper.
albiez
4/8/2003 A trade has been completed between the Philadelphia BullFrogs and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4740434]Jack Duvall[/url] from the Philadelphia BullFrogs in exchange for [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5154908]Soup Cambell[/url], [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868653]Brian Polcyn[/url].
Philadelphia approached me with this, and it was an easy call. I was about to waive both Polcyn and Cambell, and Duvall could at least fill a role as a back of the bullpen/emergency starter type guy. Philly might be able to get a decent return from this with the new minor systems, but this was really a case of me getting a mediocre player for the present in exchange for two potentially mediocre players in the future.
Polcyn will always be a "what if" type of guy for me - he was drafted as a 19 year-old with a great bundle in the third round of the same draft where I picked up [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868667]Ariza[/url], [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868663]Urbino[/url], and [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868592]Pablo[/url]. I also had [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4643507]Arcadio[/url] needing CPs, and snagged [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868551]Ruhlman[/url] off of waiver. I was able to trade for 5 CPs, but not 10, and decided to CP Ruhlman over Polcyn because I felt like I had enough pitching. No one wanted to trade for him because they had their own prospects from the deep draft, so instead of becoming a great set-up man or pretty good closer, he's doomed to a career of mediocrity. Drafted six seasons to early for the current system, a real shame...
Duvall for prospects.
January 14, 2009 at 11:59PM View BBCode
I like this, it seems like a better way of talking about trades than offering 2 cents on someone else's business, which I was guilty of earlier today. And maybe it'll be helpful for helping us understand each other.4/8/2003 A trade has been completed between the Philadelphia BullFrogs and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4740434]Jack Duvall[/url] from the Philadelphia BullFrogs in exchange for [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5154908]Soup Cambell[/url], [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868653]Brian Polcyn[/url].
Philadelphia approached me with this, and it was an easy call. I was about to waive both Polcyn and Cambell, and Duvall could at least fill a role as a back of the bullpen/emergency starter type guy. Philly might be able to get a decent return from this with the new minor systems, but this was really a case of me getting a mediocre player for the present in exchange for two potentially mediocre players in the future.
Polcyn will always be a "what if" type of guy for me - he was drafted as a 19 year-old with a great bundle in the third round of the same draft where I picked up [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868667]Ariza[/url], [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868663]Urbino[/url], and [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868592]Pablo[/url]. I also had [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4643507]Arcadio[/url] needing CPs, and snagged [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4868551]Ruhlman[/url] off of waiver. I was able to trade for 5 CPs, but not 10, and decided to CP Ruhlman over Polcyn because I felt like I had enough pitching. No one wanted to trade for him because they had their own prospects from the deep draft, so instead of becoming a great set-up man or pretty good closer, he's doomed to a career of mediocrity. Drafted six seasons to early for the current system, a real shame...
albiez
The Cleveland deals
January 15, 2009 at 12:19AM View BBCode
Roosters summed up my trades with him pretty well. I was a little surprised that he took what he got over the offer of Ruhlman and a first, and was kind of happy he did at the time, because I tend to value contact and even bundling more than most. But with Gallegher's amazing improves over the last off-season, and health that's proved to be maxxed out, I like this trade a lot more from roosters' standpoint. I don't miss Bennett or the first rounder all that much, and they may end up being semi-useful to him in rebuild mode, so that's fine for both of us.
albiez
Pittsburgh was interested in both Palacios and Gallegher, and offered me a deal of 2 2nds and Smythe for them. After packaging Gallegher in the Dunlop acquisition while keeping Ruhlman, I just didn't have a place for Palacios to play regularly. I'm happy with this deal, as Smythe will be a servicable middle reliever in the future, and with the new CP system the pick could end up being useful as well, depending on the draft. Palacios just wasn't going to be a major contributor to my team, and his development had been harmed in 2002 when I was literally on a boat for most of the season and wasn't able to get him into the starting line-up.
Palacios to Pittsburgh
January 15, 2009 at 12:26AM View BBCode
5/1/2003 A trade has been completed between the Pittsburgh Yellowjackets and the Boston Brown Acid. The Boston Brown Acid receive [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5350388]Leonard Smythe[/url], Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (PIT) from the Pittsburgh Yellowjackets in exchange for [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5086965]Jose Palacios[/url].Pittsburgh was interested in both Palacios and Gallegher, and offered me a deal of 2 2nds and Smythe for them. After packaging Gallegher in the Dunlop acquisition while keeping Ruhlman, I just didn't have a place for Palacios to play regularly. I'm happy with this deal, as Smythe will be a servicable middle reliever in the future, and with the new CP system the pick could end up being useful as well, depending on the draft. Palacios just wasn't going to be a major contributor to my team, and his development had been harmed in 2002 when I was literally on a boat for most of the season and wasn't able to get him into the starting line-up.
albiez
Lopez is in decline, but at A-/A still has another 2 or even 3 good to useful seasons ahead of him. A play-off first (as mine is likely to be) seemed like a fair price to me, maybe even a little bit of a deal. But why make this move with my pitching depth?
Lopez to Boston?
January 15, 2009 at 12:30AM View BBCode
4/4/2004 A trade has been completed between the Boston Brown Acid and the New York Highlanders. The New York Highlanders receive Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (BOS) from the Boston Brown Acid in exchange for [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=3962231]John Lopez[/url].Lopez is in decline, but at A-/A still has another 2 or even 3 good to useful seasons ahead of him. A play-off first (as mine is likely to be) seemed like a fair price to me, maybe even a little bit of a deal. But why make this move with my pitching depth?
albiez
It's a cold world out there, and sometimes I feel like I'm getting a frosty myself.
I love Masterson, and he played a huge role in my team winning four titles in the last five years. Trading for him and [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4024172]Rip Fairbank[/url] is what really put my team over the top and propelled us onto our current run. But I had an idea that I could swing him to Chicago or somebody else for a little bit more than it would cost me to get an older but roughly as good player like Lopez, or a younger but worse starter. With Urbino looking very good and still improving, my goal was either to extend my window a little bit, or improve my minors.
With Masterson's velocity at B, and losing 7 points a year starting next season, I think that he and Lopez will be about as good as one another for the rest of their careers. I don't have much experience with declining stars, so this is admittedly a little bit of a gamble and I could quite likely end up being wrong. But at the moment I feel like I managed to pick up some position in the first round, as well as another second round pick, without sacrificing much of consequence for the present or future.
Of course, it might all blow up in my face, and maybe I should have kept both Masterson and Lopez as insurance against injury. We'll have to see! In was another kind of unconventional, sideways-seeming deal like this I was able to pick up Mahler in exchange for Noonan, and I feel like that helped me tremendously in the long run.
Masterson is a Rusty Nail
January 15, 2009 at 12:40AM View BBCode
News Story 4/8/2004 A trade has been completed between the Boston Brown Acid and the Chicago Rusty Nails. The Chicago Rusty Nails receive [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4353046]Chipper Masterson[/url] from the Boston Brown Acid in exchange for Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (CHA), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (CHA).It's a cold world out there, and sometimes I feel like I'm getting a frosty myself.
I love Masterson, and he played a huge role in my team winning four titles in the last five years. Trading for him and [url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4024172]Rip Fairbank[/url] is what really put my team over the top and propelled us onto our current run. But I had an idea that I could swing him to Chicago or somebody else for a little bit more than it would cost me to get an older but roughly as good player like Lopez, or a younger but worse starter. With Urbino looking very good and still improving, my goal was either to extend my window a little bit, or improve my minors.
With Masterson's velocity at B, and losing 7 points a year starting next season, I think that he and Lopez will be about as good as one another for the rest of their careers. I don't have much experience with declining stars, so this is admittedly a little bit of a gamble and I could quite likely end up being wrong. But at the moment I feel like I managed to pick up some position in the first round, as well as another second round pick, without sacrificing much of consequence for the present or future.
Of course, it might all blow up in my face, and maybe I should have kept both Masterson and Lopez as insurance against injury. We'll have to see! In was another kind of unconventional, sideways-seeming deal like this I was able to pick up Mahler in exchange for Noonan, and I feel like that helped me tremendously in the long run.
tworoosters
I really worship at the Temple of Power, it covers up a variety of other sins for me, which is why I chose Gallegher, and Bennett, over Ruhlman. My process was that Ruhlman's bundle negated any chance of him getting above A- in power and Gallegher's health was the kicker.
Gallegher's improves were sweet, and that's the X factor. I still think it's one of those "Win/Win" deals in that Boston gets the A+ power guy in the middle of the order to keep the run going and I get one or two blocks for the future.
As a side note, Gallegher hit 8th all season for me and drove in 97 runs while hitting .246 and slugging less than .400, that's a pretty amazing stat.
January 15, 2009 at 07:10AM View BBCode
Originally posted by albiez
Roosters summed up my trades with him pretty well. I was a little surprised that he took what he got over the offer of Ruhlman and a first, and was kind of happy he did at the time, because I tend to value contact and even bundling more than most. But with Gallegher's amazing improves over the last off-season, and health that's proved to be maxxed out, I like this trade a lot more from roosters' standpoint. I don't miss Bennett or the first rounder all that much, and they may end up being semi-useful to him in rebuild mode, so that's fine for both of us.
I really worship at the Temple of Power, it covers up a variety of other sins for me, which is why I chose Gallegher, and Bennett, over Ruhlman. My process was that Ruhlman's bundle negated any chance of him getting above A- in power and Gallegher's health was the kicker.
Gallegher's improves were sweet, and that's the X factor. I still think it's one of those "Win/Win" deals in that Boston gets the A+ power guy in the middle of the order to keep the run going and I get one or two blocks for the future.
As a side note, Gallegher hit 8th all season for me and drove in 97 runs while hitting .246 and slugging less than .400, that's a pretty amazing stat.
albiez
January 15, 2009 at 07:35AM View BBCode
Oh yeah, I'm still happy with it on my end, no real second thoughts here. I of course like power as much as the next guy, but when it's all said and done I happen to pay my observances at the Temple of OBP. Just an interesting case of two people with different philosophies - in the end I think that both of them (Ruhlman and Gallegeher) are going to have similarly good, but not great, careers. Just good in different ways.
KillerG
January 16, 2009 at 12:20AM View BBCode
When I get some time I might humor everyone with some trade reports. It will not be until Sunday/Monday at the earliest. Until then ... maybe.
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Pittsburgh Yellowjackets. The Pittsburgh Yellowjackets receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4353003]Frank Pembleton[/url],[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4740400]Lance White[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5269578]Peter Decker[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5269525]KoKo Tate[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468373]Takeshi Kovacs[/url],Draft Pick - 2004 Round 2 (PIT), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (PIT)
Pittsburgh approached me with this deal, which surprised me a bit as I didn't think they'd be in an aggressive buy mode, but I guess Gerry read the tea leaves and saw that the time was right.
I hadn't really thought about moving White too much as I was more focused on trying to deal out [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4024021]Salazar[/url] at the time but this deal had one major incentive for me that others didn't and that was Kovacs. Kovacs was 17 all year, and has 3 more years of prime teenage improves left, he has a great bundle, red letter speed and reasonable defense and health. Decker added minor league pitching depth, something I had zero of, Tate has the chance to get to "solid #4" status and the 1st round pick was a year out so I could hedge my bets.
Overall I got 5 pieces and Pittsburgh got a legitimate #1 Starter and solid Outfielder, both with a few years left. This is another win/win deal but it only really works for me if Decker makes a contribution or the 2005 draft is a good one. Still I really like Kovacs and Tate fills a spot in the rotation while we rebuild, and maybe Tate gets lucky in OS25/26 and makes A- overall. I used the 2nd round pick to acquire [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5553021]Darrow Nash[/url] who will benefit from the new CP system by getting 2-3 years of minor league improves to develop, I'm not holding my breath but if his control gets to A- he might work out OK. The 1st rounder turned into [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5697517]Gabriel Bird[/url], one of my many "suspect" pitchers taken late in round ones over theyears.
I really made this deal because I was frustrated by my inability to move Salazar and wanted to get a prime return on Pembleton while I could. I broke it down as Kovacs and the #1 for Pembleton and the rest for White, and I'm good with that.
[Edited on 8-31-2009 by tworoosters]
Pembleton and White to Pittsburgh
January 16, 2009 at 01:57PM View BBCode
06/03/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Pittsburgh Yellowjackets. The Pittsburgh Yellowjackets receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4353003]Frank Pembleton[/url],[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4740400]Lance White[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5269578]Peter Decker[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5269525]KoKo Tate[/url], [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5468373]Takeshi Kovacs[/url],Draft Pick - 2004 Round 2 (PIT), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (PIT)
Pittsburgh approached me with this deal, which surprised me a bit as I didn't think they'd be in an aggressive buy mode, but I guess Gerry read the tea leaves and saw that the time was right.
I hadn't really thought about moving White too much as I was more focused on trying to deal out [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=4024021]Salazar[/url] at the time but this deal had one major incentive for me that others didn't and that was Kovacs. Kovacs was 17 all year, and has 3 more years of prime teenage improves left, he has a great bundle, red letter speed and reasonable defense and health. Decker added minor league pitching depth, something I had zero of, Tate has the chance to get to "solid #4" status and the 1st round pick was a year out so I could hedge my bets.
Overall I got 5 pieces and Pittsburgh got a legitimate #1 Starter and solid Outfielder, both with a few years left. This is another win/win deal but it only really works for me if Decker makes a contribution or the 2005 draft is a good one. Still I really like Kovacs and Tate fills a spot in the rotation while we rebuild, and maybe Tate gets lucky in OS25/26 and makes A- overall. I used the 2nd round pick to acquire [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5553021]Darrow Nash[/url] who will benefit from the new CP system by getting 2-3 years of minor league improves to develop, I'm not holding my breath but if his control gets to A- he might work out OK. The 1st rounder turned into [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5697517]Gabriel Bird[/url], one of my many "suspect" pitchers taken late in round ones over theyears.
I really made this deal because I was frustrated by my inability to move Salazar and wanted to get a prime return on Pembleton while I could. I broke it down as Kovacs and the #1 for Pembleton and the rest for White, and I'm good with that.
[Edited on 8-31-2009 by tworoosters]
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Milwaukee Black Hats. The Milwaukee Black Hats receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4024210&statsorimps=stats]Fred Meyers[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (MIL), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 3 (MIL).
A true "deadline deal", with Milwaukee locked in a playoff battle I shipped the veteran outfielder to the Black Hats for 2 future picks. Meyers was still effective against LHP and Milwaukee ended up in the playoffs, though Fred got hurt and missed the postseason.
I get 2 future picks for a guy I just didn't need anymore so it's a good deal from my end, and res made the playoffs so it worked, short term, for him.
As it turned out neither pick had any impact, although [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5697484]Syd Fish[/url] did play a little.
[Edited on 7-29-2009 by tworoosters]
Meyers to Milwaukee
January 18, 2009 at 12:51AM View BBCode
8/30/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Milwaukee Black Hats. The Milwaukee Black Hats receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4024210&statsorimps=stats]Fred Meyers[/url] from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (MIL), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 3 (MIL).
A true "deadline deal", with Milwaukee locked in a playoff battle I shipped the veteran outfielder to the Black Hats for 2 future picks. Meyers was still effective against LHP and Milwaukee ended up in the playoffs, though Fred got hurt and missed the postseason.
I get 2 future picks for a guy I just didn't need anymore so it's a good deal from my end, and res made the playoffs so it worked, short term, for him.
As it turned out neither pick had any impact, although [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5697484]Syd Fish[/url] did play a little.
[Edited on 7-29-2009 by tworoosters]
tworoosters
A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5086981]Tim Beane[/url], Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (BOS) from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868613]Jean Barcelo[/url]
At season's end I did my "roster post mortem" and realized that:
A) I had a lot of picks in a mediocre draft
B) I didn't want to bring up [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=5154813]Barnes[/url] in 2004
C) So I needed another OF
I never really liked Beane, he's got no pop and mediocre speed, but I always liked Barcelo.
I tried a few times to get Barcelo but Philly insisted he was "one of his young up and comers", of course he also told me Serrano was "untouchable" but that's another story, but by season's end I guess the Rattler was tired of Barcelo's underacheiving so I was able to get him.
From my end I got a youngish starting OF with red letter power for a spare part and the 48th pick in the draft. My feeling was that Barcelo had at least a chance to produce while Beane never would. At this point Barcelo is sucking out loud but I'm willing to give him at least a full year to see what he can do.
Beane and a pick to Philadelphia
January 18, 2009 at 01:06AM View BBCode
10/5/2003A trade has been completed between the Cleveland Buckeyes and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=5086981]Tim Beane[/url], Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (BOS) from the Cleveland Buckeyes in exchange for [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=4868613]Jean Barcelo[/url]
At season's end I did my "roster post mortem" and realized that:
A) I had a lot of picks in a mediocre draft
B) I didn't want to bring up [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=5154813]Barnes[/url] in 2004
C) So I needed another OF
I never really liked Beane, he's got no pop and mediocre speed, but I always liked Barcelo.
I tried a few times to get Barcelo but Philly insisted he was "one of his young up and comers", of course he also told me Serrano was "untouchable" but that's another story, but by season's end I guess the Rattler was tired of Barcelo's underacheiving so I was able to get him.
From my end I got a youngish starting OF with red letter power for a spare part and the 48th pick in the draft. My feeling was that Barcelo had at least a chance to produce while Beane never would. At this point Barcelo is sucking out loud but I'm willing to give him at least a full year to see what he can do.
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive Hughie Wheat, Rod Pearson, Melvin Powell, March Hinrichs, Jean Barcelo, Tacks Shaute from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Jimmy Serrano, P.J. Wright.
If I remember right, I had a lot of spare parts. Hinrich, Barcelo, & Wheat were the center piece of the deal for Serrano & Wright. The others had potential but needed some luck and lots of playing time. I liked Wright as a young relief pitcher & Serrano's mentor score and that he was a solid performer. He turned out to be better than I thought he would & the players I traded missed their opportunity to fully develop.
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
January 18, 2009 at 02:12PM View BBCode
I'll start w/ this deal. 5/3/2001A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive Hughie Wheat, Rod Pearson, Melvin Powell, March Hinrichs, Jean Barcelo, Tacks Shaute from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Jimmy Serrano, P.J. Wright.
If I remember right, I had a lot of spare parts. Hinrich, Barcelo, & Wheat were the center piece of the deal for Serrano & Wright. The others had potential but needed some luck and lots of playing time. I liked Wright as a young relief pitcher & Serrano's mentor score and that he was a solid performer. He turned out to be better than I thought he would & the players I traded missed their opportunity to fully develop.
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive Jake Bear, P.J. Wright, Nick Galehouse from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Juan Smith, Peter O"Shea, Don Hockenbery.
Phily wanted Wright back and he asked about Jake Bear via U2U. I wanted to get rid of one of the three D health players that I had because they were always on the bench together & it was hurting my team but it was helping the developement of the bench players (DeSilva). I was moving out of the developement stage & into the contending stage & felt that I couldn't keep all three of them make the playoffs.
I feel this deal favored Phili but I also thought Smith (better health) would help me shore up the starting line up. I got the U2U & thought ... sweet ... I didn't had to contact a bunch of teams.
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
January 18, 2009 at 02:30PM View BBCode
Next trade: 4/1/2003A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Philadelphia BullFrogs. The Philadelphia BullFrogs receive Jake Bear, P.J. Wright, Nick Galehouse from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Juan Smith, Peter O"Shea, Don Hockenbery.
Phily wanted Wright back and he asked about Jake Bear via U2U. I wanted to get rid of one of the three D health players that I had because they were always on the bench together & it was hurting my team but it was helping the developement of the bench players (DeSilva). I was moving out of the developement stage & into the contending stage & felt that I couldn't keep all three of them make the playoffs.
I feel this deal favored Phili but I also thought Smith (better health) would help me shore up the starting line up. I got the U2U & thought ... sweet ... I didn't had to contact a bunch of teams.
[Edited on 1-18-2009 by KillerG]
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Cleveland Buckeyes. The Cleveland Buckeyes receive Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Dummy Dahlen.
I was looking for some backup infield help & I was surprised 2R let him go for a #3 DP. Dahlen wasn't the best right handed hitter but was a stud lefty hitter & was solid backup infielder. I thought he was a really nice fit for my team. It was a good trade for both teams.
January 18, 2009 at 02:36PM View BBCode
4/8/2003A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the Cleveland Buckeyes. The Cleveland Buckeyes receive Draft Pick - 2004 Round 3 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Dummy Dahlen.
I was looking for some backup infield help & I was surprised 2R let him go for a #3 DP. Dahlen wasn't the best right handed hitter but was a stud lefty hitter & was solid backup infielder. I thought he was a really nice fit for my team. It was a good trade for both teams.
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Philadelphia BullFrogs and the Cincinnati Cobras. The Cincinnati Cobras receive Hank Brennan from the Philadelphia BullFrogs in exchange for Bert Power, Lefty Boken.
This is were things get interesting. Brennen wasn't even in my plans but I was U2U's and asked if I was interested in him. Sure, he is a very good player but it depended on the demands. I was waiting to see what NYN was going to do ... I might have already known his plans by this time, not sure though. The next day this offer was sent and I accepted this offer. Brennen was a very nice pickup & I could replace Boken in the deal & Bert Power was available to anyone that wanted him. The team is starting to look really nice.
January 18, 2009 at 02:48PM View BBCode
10/11/2003A trade has been completed between the Philadelphia BullFrogs and the Cincinnati Cobras. The Cincinnati Cobras receive Hank Brennan from the Philadelphia BullFrogs in exchange for Bert Power, Lefty Boken.
This is were things get interesting. Brennen wasn't even in my plans but I was U2U's and asked if I was interested in him. Sure, he is a very good player but it depended on the demands. I was waiting to see what NYN was going to do ... I might have already known his plans by this time, not sure though. The next day this offer was sent and I accepted this offer. Brennen was a very nice pickup & I could replace Boken in the deal & Bert Power was available to anyone that wanted him. The team is starting to look really nice.
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the New York Highlanders. The New York Highlanders receive Art Fitzgerald, Phil Colton, Lew Reidy, Dave Downing, Draft Pick - 2004 Round 2 (CIN), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (CIN), Draft Pick - 2004 Round 1 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Richie Redmond, George Skrmetta.
As soon as NYN lost the tie breaker, I sent him a U2U. To lose like that is B.S. Then I asked if he was going into rebuild and if so, was he going to tear it all the way down. Reply was all the way down. Everyone was focused on the playoffs, I was focused on the deal. I looked up the Black Hats offer on the trade board, didn't know he was going into rebuild too. I already had worked out a deal for Redman & added the players I felt it would take to get Skrmetta. I sent a U2U & a deal before he posted his intentions to the league. He accepted.
This deal wouldn't have went down if we, the league, did not talk NYN into making a run for the playoffs that season. I told him as soon as the Black Hats deal for Skrmetta goes down ... I'll send the deal for Redman. This never happened because he made the run. By the way, Dick Croucher was the only player off the table in this deal.
I waited all season to find out NYNs intentions and acted as fast as I could to get both players. My window of opportunity is now and I had to do everything I could. 2R thanks for passing on the Wade for a #1 DP. I passed on some trades & other teams passed on some trades I sent ... I was fortunate.
NYN is rebulding, lots of good players for him but he missed his opportunity in the draft and I recieved the studs I wanted.
January 18, 2009 at 03:09PM View BBCode
10/22/2003A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the New York Highlanders. The New York Highlanders receive Art Fitzgerald, Phil Colton, Lew Reidy, Dave Downing, Draft Pick - 2004 Round 2 (CIN), Draft Pick - 2005 Round 1 (CIN), Draft Pick - 2004 Round 1 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Richie Redmond, George Skrmetta.
As soon as NYN lost the tie breaker, I sent him a U2U. To lose like that is B.S. Then I asked if he was going into rebuild and if so, was he going to tear it all the way down. Reply was all the way down. Everyone was focused on the playoffs, I was focused on the deal. I looked up the Black Hats offer on the trade board, didn't know he was going into rebuild too. I already had worked out a deal for Redman & added the players I felt it would take to get Skrmetta. I sent a U2U & a deal before he posted his intentions to the league. He accepted.
This deal wouldn't have went down if we, the league, did not talk NYN into making a run for the playoffs that season. I told him as soon as the Black Hats deal for Skrmetta goes down ... I'll send the deal for Redman. This never happened because he made the run. By the way, Dick Croucher was the only player off the table in this deal.
I waited all season to find out NYNs intentions and acted as fast as I could to get both players. My window of opportunity is now and I had to do everything I could. 2R thanks for passing on the Wade for a #1 DP. I passed on some trades & other teams passed on some trades I sent ... I was fortunate.
NYN is rebulding, lots of good players for him but he missed his opportunity in the draft and I recieved the studs I wanted.
KillerG
A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the New York Highlanders. The New York Highlanders receive Steve Thompson, Mark Hart, Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Andy Pinnance.
U2U'd NYN, getting any offers for Driscoll? He was getting none at all. Looked at NYNs roster and went for Pinnance, didn't expect the deal to be accepted and I was waiting for a counter offer. It never came because it was accepted. This deal was the icing on the cake. Before this deal, I tried to get Sims from NYA but he would not budge.
We all know the game, start low to gauge the interest because you can always go higher to make the deal work.
I also stated I would have reworked this deal to make it closer to fair, now that this much time has passed ...
January 18, 2009 at 03:23PM View BBCode
4/4/2004A trade has been completed between the Cincinnati Cobras and the New York Highlanders. The New York Highlanders receive Steve Thompson, Mark Hart, Draft Pick - 2005 Round 2 (CIN) from the Cincinnati Cobras in exchange for Andy Pinnance.
U2U'd NYN, getting any offers for Driscoll? He was getting none at all. Looked at NYNs roster and went for Pinnance, didn't expect the deal to be accepted and I was waiting for a counter offer. It never came because it was accepted. This deal was the icing on the cake. Before this deal, I tried to get Sims from NYA but he would not budge.
We all know the game, start low to gauge the interest because you can always go higher to make the deal work.
I also stated I would have reworked this deal to make it closer to fair, now that this much time has passed ...
KillerG
January 18, 2009 at 08:21PM View BBCode
If I missed something in these trades then hopefully the other owner can fill in the blanks.
tworoosters
Well I'd love to have Scubba "fill in the blanks" on the Pinnance deal.
I'd also love to know how you:
'cause I can only see my trade board not anyone else's.
January 18, 2009 at 10:56PM View BBCode
Originally posted by KillerG
If I missed something in these trades then hopefully the other owner can fill in the blanks.
Well I'd love to have Scubba "fill in the blanks" on the Pinnance deal.
I'd also love to know how you:
Originally posted by Killer G
looked up the Black Hats offer on the trade board
'cause I can only see my trade board not anyone else's.
KillerG
There was a question for help on a trade with Samcoff (stud) being the center piece of the deal for last season. It was right before NYN changed their mind about rebuilding. That deal was the one I was waiting to go down before I submitted the deal for Redman. I also was thinking the Black Hats would use that same deal to go after Skrmetta but he went into rebuild & I left my offer on the table.
We all check the team, draft, and trade help message board at some time, right? Great place to get info.
January 19, 2009 at 02:36PM View BBCode
Sorry, the team, draft, and trade help message board.There was a question for help on a trade with Samcoff (stud) being the center piece of the deal for last season. It was right before NYN changed their mind about rebuilding. That deal was the one I was waiting to go down before I submitted the deal for Redman. I also was thinking the Black Hats would use that same deal to go after Skrmetta but he went into rebuild & I left my offer on the table.
We all check the team, draft, and trade help message board at some time, right? Great place to get info.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32